When it comes to the new hybrid car market, consumers really are spoiled for choice. Brands across the globe are throwing considerable resources at electrification, with gasoline-electric hybrids being the strongest product in terms of demand by a massive margin. The two front-runners in the American hybrid market are Honda and Toyota, including the Lexus division. These are two brands that are typically associated with affordability, efficiency, and reliability, while Lexus introduces quality to the mix with a noticeable price increase. For many prospective buyers, reliability is a very important factor when considering a new vehicle.
These three brands typically benefit from the best reputations in terms of reliability, but the big question is which brand stands out on top, especially when looking at their HEV ranges? The best way to approach this is by analyzing each respective brand’s most popular HEV SUV option, which are the Honda CR-V Hybrid, Toyota RAV4, and Lexus RX 350h. These are three monikers that enjoy a strong and long-standing reputation among American car owners, primarily thanks to their impressive reliability track record. Adding HEV drivetrains into the mix improves their efficiency and long-term cost factor.
Toyota vs Honda: The Most Reliable Hybrid SUV For 2025
The reliability race is close between the Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V Hybrid.
The Lexus RX Sets The Standard For Reliability
85/100 Reliability Score Makes It A Solid Hybrid SUV In Terms Of Fuss-Free Ownership
The Lexus RX 350h achieves impressive ratings across all of its testing thanks to its well-balanced design. J.D. Power issues the model with an 85/100 overall score, which consists of 85/100 for quality and reliability, 82/100 for the driving experience, 84/100 for resale, and 87/100 for the dealership experience. The same publication also reveals that Lexus ranks the highest among all brands when it comes to vehicle dependability for three consecutive years in a row. Toyota ranks fourth, while Honda slots in at 12th. These results are based on the 2025 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study, which reflects a six percent increase in problems per 100 vehicles compared to a year ago.
iSeeCars backs this with an 8.3/10 overall score, including 8.6/10 for reliability, 8.2/10 for retained value, and 8.0/10 for safety. The publication also indicates that you can expect the RX 350h to last you 14.7 years or 170,975 miles before you encounter any noteworthy mechanical issues, with a 31.7-percent probability of reaching 200,000 miles.
Based on this, the Lexus RX Hybrid acts as a representative for the brand’s title as the manufacturer of the most reliable hybrid SUV currently available on the market. This is an interesting revelation, because it features an identical drivetrain to the aforementioned RAV4 Hybrid.
iSeeCars also highlights that the RX 350h will lose $22,409 or 43.8 percent of its value after five years or 60,000 miles, which is more than 10 percent better than what its main rivals struggle with.
Find 2020 Lexus RX and more cars for sale on our Marketplace
Lexus RX Hybrid Five-Year Cost-To-Own
Edmunds doesn’t have any data on the Lexus RX 350h, but if we look at the 350 range, which is mechanically identical, sans the electrical system, we see that you can expect to spend $77,377 on the luxury SUV over five years and 60,000 miles. This includes $23,164 on depreciation, $10,426 on maintenance, and $1,465 on repairs.
According to CarEdge, the Lexus RX Hybrid will cost you $57,867 over five years and 60,000 miles. This includes $25,704 on depreciation, $12,910 on insurance, $6,415 on fuel, $10,246 on financing, and $2,592 on maintenance.
What RX 350h Owners Have To Say
The Lexus RX Hybrid currently has a 4.3/5 average score on the Edmunds consumer review section, 70 percent of which are five-star ratings. The NHTSA only lists one active recall for the Lexus RX Hybrid related to a damaged second-row seat belt.
|
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
|
|
The Most Reliable Lexus Hybrid SUV You Can Buy Today
Japan pioneered the hybrid and now dominates the sector, and here’s an SUV from Lexus that is the most reliable one you can buy today.
The Honda CR-V Hybrid’s Trustworthy Reputation
A Score Of 84/100 Puts It Just Behind The Lexus
J.D. Power gives the Honda CR-V range an 84/100 quality and reliability score, 85/100 score for resale, 83/100 for the driving experience, and 81/100 dealership experience score, bringing its overall consumer-verified rating up to 83/100. iSeeCars holds a similar sentiment with the CR-V Hybrid, highlighting that it will lose 43 percent or $14,755 of its value after five years, resulting in the Japanese HEV SUV earning an 8.0/10 retained value score.
2025 Honda CR-V Hybrid True Cost To Own
| Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance | $678 | $702 | $726 | $752 | $778 | $3,636 |
| Maintenance | $183 | $632 | $353 | $2,098 | $2,371 | $5,637 |
| Repairs | $0 | $0 | $87 | $209 | $305 | $601 |
| Taxes & Fees | $1,776 | $93 | $93 | $93 | $93 | $2,148 |
| Financing | $2,123 | $1,713 | $1,273 | $798 | $290 | $6,197 |
| Depreciation | $3,145 | $1,800 | $1,702 | $1,997 | $1,891 | $10,535 |
| Fuel | $1,106 | $1,139 | $1,174 | $1,209 | $1,245 | $5,873 |
| True Cost to Own | $9,011 | $6,079 | $5,408 | $7,156 | $6,973 | $34,627 |
According to Edmunds, the base Honda CR-V Sport Hybrid loses $10,535 of its $35,630 base MSRP over the course of five years and 60,000 miles, which is an incredible value retention rate by midsize SUV standards. You can also expect to spend $5,637 on maintenance and $601 on repairs. Using similar metrics, CarEdge indicates that the very same model loses 34 percent of its value, resulting in it being worth $23,507.
Find 2025 Honda CR-V Hybrid and more cars for sale on our Marketplace
What CR-V Hybrid Owners Have To Say
The Honda CR-V Hybrid currently has a 4.2/5 average score on the Edmunds consumer review section, 63 percent of which are five-star ratings. There are currently three active recalls for the Honda CR-V Hybrid related to an improperly installed fuel house, high-pressure fuel pump leak, and a bad power-steering motor.
|
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
|
|
10 Lexus Hybrid Models You Should Buy Used
Lexus offers some of the most reliable hybrid vehicles you can get. Whether you’re on a budget or have some money to spend, Lexus has you covered.
The RAV4 Hybrid Wins Many Hearts
It Is The Most Reliable Toyota Hybrid SUV With A Score Of 80/100
The RAV4 Hybrid benefits from Toyota’s strong presence in the hybrid market , where it is recognized as a leader due to its early adoption of hybrid technology and consistent refinement of its models.
This version of the RAV4 sips fuel like an economy car and yet still delivers surprisingly good performance, but that’s not all. The steering is pleasantly quick for an agile feel, and the ride quality is excellent.
J.D. Power‘s valuation of the RAV4 Hybrid, which consists of a reasonably impressive 80/100 quality and reliability rating, resulting in an 80/100 overall score. iSeeCars backs this with an 8.7/10 reliability score, citing that it will benefit from a 14.4-year lifespan and cover 173,295 miles without any reliability issues.
According to CarEdge‘s depreciation calculator, the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid retains more value than most HEV SUVs in the U.S. thanks to its strong brand reputation, high consumer demand, and proven long-term reliability. Toyota has built a reputation for producing durable vehicles with low maintenance costs, which translates to higher resale values.
2025 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid LE True Cost To Own
According to Edmunds, you can expect to spend $34,400 over the course of five years and 60,000 miles on the base Toyota RAV4 Hybrid LE. $4,974 accounts for maintenance, $690 for repairs, $9,891 for depreciation, and $6,030 for fuel.
Find 2024 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid and more cars for sale on our Marketplace
What RAV4 Hybrid Owners Have To Say
The Toyota RAV4 Hybrid currently has a 4.4/5 average score on the Edmunds consumer review section, 70 percent of which are five-star ratings. The NHTSA only lists one active recall for the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid related to a possible instrument panel failure.
|
Strengths |
Weaknesses |
|
|